as discussion about branding, as the main logo is changed, add a mention that Plasma is a KDE project in a fine print on the bottom of the screen
Details
- Reviewers
- None
- Group Reviewers
Plasma - Commits
- R120:ffc54b84bda5: add a "Plasma made by KDE" sign in the splash
R871:ffc54b84bda5: add a "Plasma made by KDE" sign in the splash
displays correctly in the splash as the attached screenshot
if this is a good change or not i don't have much opinion
Diff Detail
- Repository
- R120 Plasma Workspace
- Lint
Automatic diff as part of commit; lint not applicable. - Unit
Automatic diff as part of commit; unit tests not applicable.
If I may add a slightly unrelated comment - the circly parts of the new logo seem to throw the spinner a bit off visually, I think it could use some larger spacing in between those two.
As I wasn't around on IRC: why not translatable? In general I dislike English branding on products. If I'm using a German localization I also want to have the product tagline in German. If it's English, people don't understand it. The most common example for that is "Douglas, come in and find out", which reads to Germans as "go in and find the exit". Similar I just googled for "Volkswagen Das Auto" - German tagline used internationally. And all you find is "What does it mean?" Taglines need to be translated IMHO.
I fear it might become some rubbish as "durch KDE" or "gemacht von KDE" or "Hersgestellt von KDE". I somewhat agree with you though, partially.
Also, everyone with recent Frameworks, even on 5.8, will get the new Plasma logo, without the KDE tag…
in that case we need a clear context. Including things like "this is the first thing our users will see. Don't make us look embarrassing"
I'm personally very happy to see the byline. While I agree the rebranding and establishing a Plasma logo/brand are smart and important, the backing identity of the KDE community is emotionally important to me, and seeing it represented at login both feels good as well as adds an element of the product understanding its roots and being proud of its heritage.
now it's actual text with along explanation inthe i18nc, spinner balanced in the bottom third
Maybe a little bigger gap between text and logo and align the text to baseline of the logo? The latter could be better or worse, not sure. Gap would be good tho.
k, let's go with vert-centered and a sliiightly bigger gap then maybe?
btw: I think the "made by KDE" actually helps reinforce the new branding/brand relationship (this is Plasma, KDE makes Plasma, KDE != Plasma).
as the plasma logo is not well recognized yet I would add on bottom to the plasma logo a text field like plasma made by KDE
wouldn't add another thext label around, cluttered enough already, if to add Plasma, i would just make the message "Plasma made by KDE"