Create a catalog of KDE Verified hardware
Open, WishlistPublic

Description

Why does it need to be done?

KDE Patrons have a portfolio of devices that ship with Linux, but if you look at all the options available for a customer, choosing a Linux device narrows their options significantly.
Existing users thinking about purchasing a new device would have much more options if KDE maintained a catalog of devices that work well with KDE.

What it will take

We'd need to make a standard test that every qualifying device would need to pass.
Something like:

  • General hardware compatibility on a distro chosen by the manufacturer. Cameras, fingerprint readers, keyboard backlights, sleep/wake, graphics etc. have to work out of the box
  • Features in Plasma (like power-profiles and battery limits, screen brightness) that are hardware-specific need to work
  • The device should be openable and repairable
  • The device should use as many sustainable materials as possible
  • The device should have long-time firmware support / updates and warranty from the manufacturer
  • The manufacturer's utilities should work well on Plasma
  • In cases when something doesn't work out of the box, there should be documentation and tools to easily fix problems

Depending on how many of these criteria are met, KDE Verified would have different tiers (similar to Steam Deck verified, for ex.)
It would start by testing our patron's devices, they would of course stay the most important part of the ecosystem, they would be in the highest tier

How does it connect to KDE's vision of "A world in which everyone has control over their digital life and enjoys freedom and privacy"?
If more users use devices that are compatible with Plasma, the overall user experience improves for them. People with verified devices are more likely to give Plasma a shot if they know it’s going to work smoothly on their hardware. Plus, KDE would continue to promote the use of repairable devices.

How would it affect different parts of KDE?
Plasma would have to work more often on hardware compatibility, but manufacturers would hopefully contribute more often as well.

How we know we succeeded

This project wouldn't bring quick results, but if we are persistent, after few years KDE could have a much larger catalog of devices that surely work with Plasma.
Getting devices to test would of course be a problem, and in the start we'd probably rely on random people testing their devices or sending them to someone for testing. As KDE goes forward with world domination, however, working on partnerships with established OEMs can become more viable.
In the long term, KDE could even charge companies a small fee to promote their products with the KDE Verified virtual badges, banners, or physical stickers.

Relevant links

https://kde.org/hardware/

Champions

The team is:

  • XXX
  • XXX
  • XXX

I am willing to put work into this

  • add your name

I am interested

  • add your name
aronkvh created this task.Jun 29 2024, 11:27 AM
lydia triaged this task as Wishlist priority.Jun 29 2024, 11:43 AM
lydia updated the task description. (Show Details)

Interesting goal, but I'm not really sure if this is a worthy goal. We don't make hardware, and we (usually, except for Neon) don't make distributions. Some of this stuff *could* be verified by us, such as:

The device should be openable and repairable
The device should use as many sustainable materials as possible
The device should have long-time firmware support / updates and warranty from the manufacturer

But other things depend on lots of stuff out of our control:

General hardware compatibility on a distro chosen by the manufacturer. Cameras, fingerprint readers, keyboard backlights, sleep/wake, graphics etc. have to work out of the box
Features in Plasma (like power-profiles and battery limits, screen brightness) that are hardware-specific need to work

Would this goal include getting some kind of paid contractors together to work on support for devices, or...?

Also your goal needs at least one champion to be eligible to vote.

I'd be happy to work on this of course, but so far not many people (=0) are interested to be in the team.
This would work best if the nth iteration of the "what to do with neon" discussion moves a lot forward as well - since neon (=and Tuxedo OS) is shipping on consumer hardware already.
It could include contractors working on hardware/distro compatibility, but the end goal is that manufacturers themselves will work more on being KDE-compatible.

Basically how I think it could work is: The OEM picks a distro they support the most, and their default config/image is used for the tests.
So KDE would not be the primary one to work on the distros and hardware compatibility - we would verify that the integrations work well, and most of all work well with KDE software.

frdbr added a subscriber: frdbr.Jul 29 2024, 3:54 PM
frdbr added a comment.Aug 12 2024, 7:37 PM

Hello,

Please note that the deadline just around the corner on Wednesday, so now is the time to finalize your proposal. Remember that proposals without a Goal Champion will be disqualified, so this step is crucial to ensure your idea moves forward. If you need help or have any questions, please let me know.

If you’re unable to finish your proposal but still want to participate, consider contributing to other ongoing tasks.

Thank you for submitting your ideas for the KDE Goals!