Index: kate/katedocmanager.cpp
===================================================================
--- kate/katedocmanager.cpp
+++ kate/katedocmanager.cpp
@@ -584,7 +584,11 @@
     }
     disconnect(doc, SIGNAL(completed()), this, SLOT(documentOpened()));
     disconnect(doc, SIGNAL(canceled(QString)), this, SLOT(documentOpened()));
-    if (doc->openingError()) {
+    // Checking both, openingError and isEmpty, does not only avoid to show an empty pop dialog
+    // but also to not set "openSuccess" which cause a false close in closeOrphaned() when the
+    // file has some other trouble, but exist.
+    // This works now only due to the patch introduced this comment, but is no sane solution -> FIXME
+    if (doc->openingError() && !doc->openingErrorMessage().isEmpty()) {
         m_openingErrors += QLatin1Char('\n') + doc->openingErrorMessage() + QStringLiteral("\n\n");
         KateDocumentInfo *info = documentInfo(doc);
         if (info) {