diff --git a/src/ExportManager.h b/src/ExportManager.h
--- a/src/ExportManager.h
+++ b/src/ExportManager.h
@@ -20,6 +20,7 @@
 #ifndef EXPORTMANAGER_H
 #define EXPORTMANAGER_H
 
+#include <QDir>
 #include <QObject>
 #include <QIODevice>
 #include <QPrinter>
@@ -81,7 +82,8 @@
 
     QString makeAutosaveFilename();
     using FileNameAlreadyUsedCheck = bool (ExportManager::*)(const QUrl&) const;
-    QString autoIncrementFilename(const QString &baseName, const QString &extension,
+    QString autoIncrementFilename(const QDir &baseDir, const QString &fileName,
+                                  const QString &extension,
                                   FileNameAlreadyUsedCheck isFileNameUsed);
     QString makeSaveMimetype(const QUrl &url);
     bool writeImage(QIODevice *device, const QByteArray &format);
diff --git a/src/ExportManager.cpp b/src/ExportManager.cpp
--- a/src/ExportManager.cpp
+++ b/src/ExportManager.cpp
@@ -19,7 +19,6 @@
 
 #include "ExportManager.h"
 
-#include <QDir>
 #include <QMimeDatabase>
 #include <QImageWriter>
 #include <QTemporaryDir>
@@ -130,8 +129,7 @@
 {
     const QString baseDir = saveLocation();
     const QDir baseDirPath(baseDir);
-    const QString filename = makeAutosaveFilename();
-    const QString fullpath = autoIncrementFilename(baseDirPath.filePath(filename),
+    const QString fullpath = autoIncrementFilename(baseDirPath, makeAutosaveFilename(),
                                                    SpectacleConfig::instance()->saveImageFormat(),
                                                    &ExportManager::isFileExists);
 
@@ -160,24 +158,30 @@
                    .replace(QLatin1String("%S"), timestamp.toString(QStringLiteral("ss")));
 }
 
-QString ExportManager::autoIncrementFilename(const QString &baseName, const QString &extension,
+QString ExportManager::autoIncrementFilename(const QDir &baseDir, const QString &fileName,
+                                             const QString &extension,
                                              FileNameAlreadyUsedCheck isFileNameUsed)
 {
-    if (!((this->*isFileNameUsed)(QUrl::fromUserInput(baseName + QLatin1Char('.') + extension)))) {
-        return baseName + QLatin1Char('.') + extension;
+    QString resultFileName = fileName.isEmpty() ? QStringLiteral("1") : fileName;
+    QString resultFilePath = baseDir.filePath(resultFileName) + QLatin1Char('.') + extension;
+
+    if (!((this->*isFileNameUsed)(QUrl::fromUserInput(resultFilePath)))) {
+        return resultFilePath;
     }
 
-    QString fileNameFmt(baseName + QStringLiteral("-%1.") + extension);
+    QString fileNameFmt = fileName.isEmpty() ? QStringLiteral("%1") : fileName + QStringLiteral("-%1");
+    QString filePathFmt = baseDir.filePath(fileNameFmt) + QLatin1Char('.') + extension;
+
     for (quint64 i = 1; i < std::numeric_limits<quint64>::max(); i++) {
-        if (!((this->*isFileNameUsed)(QUrl::fromUserInput(fileNameFmt.arg(i))))) {
-            return fileNameFmt.arg(i);
+        if (!((this->*isFileNameUsed)(QUrl::fromUserInput(filePathFmt.arg(i))))) {
+            return filePathFmt.arg(i);
         }
     }
 
     // unlikely this will ever happen, but just in case we've run
     // out of numbers
 
-    return fileNameFmt.arg(QStringLiteral("OVERFLOW-") + QString::number(qrand() % 10000));
+    return filePathFmt.arg(QStringLiteral("OVERFLOW-") + QString::number(qrand() % 10000));
 }
 
 QString ExportManager::makeSaveMimetype(const QUrl &url)
@@ -254,8 +258,7 @@
         // supports the use-case of creating multiple screenshots in a row
         // and exporting them to the same destination e.g. via clipboard,
         // where the temp file name is used as filename suggestion
-        const QString baseFileName = mTempDir->path() + QDir::separator() + makeAutosaveFilename();
-        const QString fileName = autoIncrementFilename(baseFileName, mimetype,
+        const QString fileName = autoIncrementFilename(mTempDir->path(), makeAutosaveFilename(), mimetype,
                                                        &ExportManager::isTempFileAlreadyUsed);
         QFile tmpFile(fileName);
         if (tmpFile.open(QFile::WriteOnly)) {